Thursday, May 24, 2012

Doth men protest too much?

smaller text tool iconmedium text tool iconlarger text tool icon

Richard_Hardiman_opt2Yes, I think they do

 History is littered with women at the forefront of industry, innovation and war. From Nobel Prize winners of the likes of Madame Curie, through to the exploits of Cleopatra and the veritable warmongering of Boadicea – women in charge and leading from the front is not uncommon and, if anything, is a well-documented occurrence.

 So how is it that after centuries of proof that the female species is on par if not well ahead of the male pack in so many ways, firstly does society allow for the questioning of whether women or men are better at almost everything? And secondly, who is doing most of the asking?

 I would venture that my answer to the first question would relate directly to the answer of the second. In both cases, it is the tribe of Adam. To me, the 1980s were particularly bad for the image of women in business. Growing up in the era of JR Ewing as I did, women were made to look as though the better looking they were, the greater chance we had of either seducing them or hiring them as an office secretary.


Newer news items:
Older news items:

 Dolly Parton in the movie Nine to Five may have taken some revenge for the female species, but not without a theme song and a shotgun. Even at that tender age, there seemed to me a dire need for women to exist in business on a level footing without the need for weaponry or the ability to type 60 words a minute. I have no doubt that competition is healthy, but there is as yet no proof that men are winning the supposed “Olympics of the species” or, in fact, anything close. What is clear, though, is that it is predominantly men who are the ones who question the effectiveness of women, rather than the other way around.

 Are we on the back foot, perhaps? Doth we protest too much? Feeling threatened, JR? Women have plenty of icons in daily life to cheer-lead their own cause. From Oprah to the now defunct Spice Girls and the “Girl Power” movement through to Republican Tea Party matron Sarah Palin, they represent the mere tip of the iceberg of ways women publicly express presence and power. It is only the men who feel the need to comment on it – and rarely with much positivism.

 Despite Darwin, are we still clinging onto the hope that the good old days of hunter-gathering will return and when it does, our women will be back at the cave waiting for us to arrive home so that they can start skinning the dinosaur and preparing dinner? Do we perhaps think that no one gives men enough credit for what we do? There is an argument that women will take action to be recognised based on the fact that they have succeeded in male-dominated areas despite being female. It is a circular and negative argument, though. We have achieved despite our own or, rather, society’s expectations.

 Men do not have that luxury. We are often expected to achieve, as society is bred to believe – rightly or wrongly – that we are the dominant sex. When we achieve, often there is no cheer-leading for having done so – the Backstreet Boys may just have failed the male species in not coming up with a “Boy Power” campaign.

 Men are simply expected to win or provide or succeed. When they do not, they are by perception failures. This may well explain our possible unconscious lack of recognition of the female ability. In our world, it is expected, rather than something to be spotlighted. Politics and business are no longer the domains of the male. Australia, as recently as June, elected its first female leader in Julia Gillard; Germany, one of the business powerhouses of the globe, has a female chancellor, Angela Merkel.

 Even television has allowed a woman to be captain of a Starfleet vessel in Star Trek. Put that in your pipe and smoke it, Sue Ellen! We have to reach an age at some point in time where the battle of the sexes is merely a reference to an age where we had ludicrous ideas about the male-female species. As with apartheid and gay rights, we would one day look back and say, “We did what? How on earth did that even fly as an idea?”

 So where do we start? We drop the male ego bit and stop throwing in the odd but incredibly damaging references to our female counterparts as being fortunate to be there; or the fact that they got there by some sort of femme fatal move rather than sheer hard work
and ability.

 We get on with it all together, accept each other for our complementary strengths, and stop looking for excuses or the opportunity to take a potshot. It is simple in theory but tough in practice.

 The old adage of men being nowhere without women can as easily be reversed – and reversed again. Nothing happens without the other. It is elementary, Mrs Watson. Now let us get on with it. ▲

 

Richard Hardiman

 

Comments (0)
Write comment
Your Contact Details:
Comment:
Security
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.
Move
-

Recent Articles

Top Headline

Football watch

Football watch

Pirates do it again Benni McCarthy for Orlando Pirates and Didier Drogba for Chelsea dominated the  highlight packages of the past week’s football. Both secured a league trophy for their respective teams with match-winning performances.

Read More...

Rugby watch

Rugby watch

SA teams dominate the Super 15 log The DHL Stormers are back at the summit of the Vodacom Super Rugby log thanks to another dedicated defensive effort against the Waratahs. With the Bulls and the Sharks, after a bonus-point win over the Free State Cheetahs, three South African teams are now amongst the top six in the Super 15 competition....

Read More...

Europe

Europe

The socio-political spinoff of economic difficulty Most of the attention in Europe since the election shocks in France and Greece has been focused on whether France and Germany can keep a solid working relationship going in dealing with the continent's protracted financial crisis. However, deeper analysis suggests that the European...

Read More...

Local Politics

Local Politics

The broader picture behind the DA and Cosatu clash With 75%, or three million, of South Africans aged between 18 and 34 unemployed, last week’s clash between the Democratic Alliance (DA) and the South African Congress of Trade Unions (Cosatu) is but the tip of the iceberg of a complex problem. Much more is at stake than just the...

Read More...

Worth a read

Worth a read

Apartheid’s Endgame Endgame is a book about South Africa's recent political history that saw the end of apartheid and the pre-dawn of democracy. It also has a lot to say about the now and the hopes and the fears for the country's future.

Read More...
Leadership magazine is South Africa's number one award winning business magazine having won the Tabbie Gold Award for Best Single Issue in the world (TABPI), PICA Awards for Magazine of the Year, Best Publication, Editor of the Year, Cover Design

The Leadership Bullentin


Archive