Thursday, September 09, 2010

Political tension

smaller text tool iconmedium text tool iconlarger text tool icon

TerreblanceTerre'Blanche murder threatens violent conflict

Never, since the slaying of struggle icon Chris Hani by right-wing extremists just days short of 17 years ago in April 1993, has South Africa been more in danger of descending into violent political conflict than after the murder this weekend of the leader of the Afrikaner Weerstandsbeweging (AWB), Eugene Terre'Blanche. To date, the reaction and commentary from most quarters has been remarkably restrained, but how well the country gets through this will depend largely on how well leaders of all persuasions succeed in keeping the rhetoric of hot-headed followers toned down.

In last week’s Bulletin, it was reported that provocative pronouncements from ANC Youth League leader Julius Malema, his PAC counterpart Pitso Mphasha and loose cannon singer Steve Hofmeyr have taken the “political temperature to dangerous levels”. We further reported on a letter by ex-state president FW de Klerk, warning about a volatile atmosphere in “our national debate”, creating a situation “in which any additional intemperate statement or action might spark an unfortunate incident.”

Whether it was purely a “wage dispute”, as is widely reported, which sparked the murder of Terre'Blanche, remains to be clarified by the due process of law. It would, however, be naive to expect that the murder would not be linked to the highly provocative way in which Malema in recent times has been using the old struggle song “Dubula iBhunu” to whip up emotions.

Perhaps it was fortuitous that Malema was outside the country when the murder occurred, although he used the opportunity outside South Africa's borders to mock the judicial system on the issue of the song. Security and intelligence experts warn that the way in which the ANC and President Jacob Zuma in particular manage what has become known as the "Malema situation", will be crucial in avoiding an escalation of tension and restoring calm.

At this stage, they have been impressed impressed with the calm, swift and responsible way in which Police Minister Nathi Mthethwa has responded to the situation. The Terre'Blanche family also has come in for some praise for the calm and dignified way in which they have handled the situation.


Wide reaction

While some of the exchanges on the social networks and in the comments sections of electronic news reporting have been heated and expose the still deep racial divides on all sides in the South African society, public utterances have been very restrained and balanced in general.

The murder received very extensive international media coverage. Within 48 hours after the event Google News listed almost 2 000 news reports worldwide. Most of the reports referred to Terreblanche as a “white supremacist” leader and many highlighted the danger of escalating conflict on the eve of the Fifa Soccer World Cup (WC) taking place in the country.

How the government and other prominent political players handle developments in the days ahead, will play an important role in determining the impact of the incident on international attendance at the WC. Many commentators on social media networks and in comment sections of news sites are referring to the unfortunate timing of the incident so shortly before the start of the WC.

In the main, all organisations and prominent commentators have condemned the murder, notwithstanding the political differences they might have had with Terre'Blanche, and have called for calm.

Hofmeyr, an apparent self-appointed spokesperson for Afrikaners, again has been a notable exception, saying about Malema and Terre'Blanche: “He must be buried at the Peter Mokaba Stadium to remind everyone about the man who is responsible for the chant 'Kill the Boer, Kill the Farmer'.”

Some observers have been expressing surprise that the human rights group Afriforum has allowed Hofmeyr to jump onto its bandwagon to the extent that he has in recent weeks. Others have suggested that it may help to bring some balance into the public debate on hate speech if someone took Hofmeyr to court on that count for some of the racist remarks on his blog.

President Zuma immediately appealed for calm “following this terrible deed", and asks South Africans not to allow provocateurs to take advantage of this situation by inciting or fuelling racial hatred. “In any dispute, especially in a country like South Africa where we uphold the rule of law, no one is allowed to take the law into his own hands,” Zuma said.

“It is against this background that the murder of Terre’Blanche must be condemned, irrespective of how his killers think they may have been justified. They had no right to take his life.” Zuma said he “condemns in the strongest possible terms” the killing of Terre’Blanche and also offered condolences to his family.

But there were also false notes from elsewhere. ANC spokesperson Jackson Mthembu, while appealing for “calmness and non-provocation at this time because the police are hard at work dealing with this matter”, found it necessary to defend Malema: he was not to blame for polarisation, or the singing of the controversial “shoot the boer” song.

“Julius has not acted in a manner that promotes polarisation. The song is not a Julius song... it is an ANC song. If you have problems with the song, we say put it to the ANC... If this song is creating problems, tell the ANC... and they will look at it.”

However, AWB general-secretary Andre Visagie said the party blamed Malema for the murder and threatened revenge. In a telephone interview with the "Weekend Post", he is reported to have said: “We are going to finish with funeral arrangements and thereafter have a summit conference on May 1 in Pretoria, where all our leaders and members of AWB will come together and decide what actions we will take to revenge Terre’Blanche’s death."

It will call for wise heads and guards in front of many a mouth in the days and weeks ahead to avoid tensions escalating out of hand.

Comments (8)
  • Gerda
    How can President Zuma appeal to South Africans to stay calm if he does not reprimand the people responsible for insighting violence? We do not need this kind of people in our country. The "struggle" for democracy is over, more than 16 years ago! People aren't idiots. "Kill the Boer" is not some kind of poetry which is to be interpreted as "love thy neigbour" or what ever else the ANC wants us to believe. The poorest are tired of waiting for the ANC to deliver on their promises made before every election. Therefor all the violent strikes. The ANC in turn are using the frustration of these people and directing the blame away from themselves towards the white so called "Boers" by sweeping up the masses with songs like this.
  • Dave
    How many farmers have been killed and murdered and the media has kept this under wraps.Now this is a reality and proves just how bad the situation really is when a house hold name has been brutally murdered.Why should this be acceptable, and a way of life for all South Africans.Lets make our voices heard and put a stop to this once and for all
  • icewoman  - Stats and static
    I did some maths ... 3 000 farmers in 16 years boils down to 3 farmers a week over 16 years
    You can work that back with murders, rapes, robberies, road accidents and abuse ... stop labelling it with colour, creed and politics. It is a travesty that we haven't yet said "South Africans are killing each other"

    We live in times of hatred greed and abuse of power ... when is the common man going to make his vote real and his voice heard.

    We need to stand for something before we fall for anything. We are being convinced of half truths and political parties win all ... the man in the street is fearful and lost without trust

    This is our land ... soil so red from the blood shed ... when will the peace come?
  • Angaas  - Who's Kidding
    A under aged child confesses to the murder, who can't be prosecuted. The only "boer" killers that the cops have caught and in record time as well. Current farm labourers charge 4 times the wages the murderers claim to be working for, how come their union didn't step in? This at a time when Malema is trying to revive something that died 15 years ago when he was still a teenager. Too many co-incidences to be believable. It sounds political and worse still conceived by the Zimbabwe CIO or a similar brainless organisation.
  • STUART SCULLY  - ANGER !!!!!
    It is such a pity that the anger of the masses, and I'd be angry too, is being directed in completely the wrong direction. To murder ET will not improve the life of ANYBODY! All people in this country are hurting due to financial woes, some more than others. Bottom line is, you have to eat! Killing farmers is really going to improve the situation? I think not! To get back to my point, the blame for the current and ongoing financial crisis in South Africa lies squarely on the shoulders of the ANC government. The black man's lot in South Africa, apart from the fat cat RANGE ROVER owners, is not a happy one. It is a daily struggle just to survive.

    Any ordinary man, regardless of color, would be justified in being unhappy with this and would wish to change the situation. The more desperate this person becomes, the more radical approach he will take. Human nature, both you and I would react the same way. The ONLY people who can change this situation is the government. Not by bbbee (it changes so I'm not sure how many b's or e's?) but by the one and only cure, EDUCATION!!!!! How can you gainfully employ anyone who has NO IDEA WHAT HE IS DOING. How can you expect to find a job WHEN YOU HAVE NO EDUCATION OR TRAINING. How can you expect intelligent voting results WHEN THE PEOPLE DO NOT KNOW HOW TO VOTE!

    And therein lies the rub! The government is ACTIVELY AND CONSISTENTLY SUPPRESSING THEIR OWN PEOPLE TO KEEP THE VOTE! The last thing the government needs is an intelligent, well informed and well educated voter base. THEY KNOW that if this was the case, they would, without any doubt, BE VOTED OUT OF POWER AT THE NEXT ELECTION.

    So my fellow South Africans, of all colors, I feel that while anger is justified, direct your anger WHERE IT IS DESERVED! The ANC government is soley responsible for the situation we find ourselves in and it condones any kind of unrest, BECAUSE IT PROTECTS THEIR VOTER BASE! ET may not have been everyones ideal man, but he was an EMPLOYER and in this way helped, in a small way, to IMPROVE THE SITUATION. (The pay dispute I can't comment on)
    The average white man in the street CAN DO VERY LITTLE to change the situation of the poorer people of this country and I firmly believe that if there was anything significant we could do, apart from voting for a sane political party, which we already do, WE WOULD DO IT!!

    They, the ANC government, should all hang their heads in shame at what THEY ARE DOING TO THEIR OWN PEOPLE.
  • THE TRUTH AND RECONCILATION PA  - THE TRUTH AND RECONCILATION PARTY OF SOUTH AFRICA
    THE TRUTH AND RECONCILATION PARTY OF SOUTH AFRICA

    The result of the death of Eugene Terreblanche leaves the TRPSA stunned and shocked and it is indeed an unfortunate and unnecessary occurrence.

    The TRPSA expresses its condolences to the family of Eugene Terreblanche and wishes his family God's Speed.

    We are mindful of how it can occur that a wage disagreement in a normal society would end in a murder, where channels, including courts, exist to resolve labor disputes.

    It is with deep regret that the radical elements of South Africa are unable to reach reconciliation and that war and hate mongers continue to incite violence and hatred and threaten violence and use opportune slogans, political rhetoric and simple mindedness to return to the earlier and maybe darker times in South African history.

    It is high time people started to do co-operative and constructive work in order to rebuild the country and improve their lives instead of indulging in short term destructive activities, mindlessness and idle chatter of the "lunatic fringe ", mindless and ignorant masses.

    The objectives of our country should not be mudslinging but rather education, job creation, industrialization, academic research and development of a constitutional democracy in order to create a South Africa where all persons born therein can live in peace if not also in harmony.

    And hopefully where reconciliation after centuries of apparently exploited lifestyles, which may require evolution and refinement, can be completed if not in very least conducted in a fashion.

    The TRPSA endorses rule of law and prevailing of accurate justice and full consideration of all relevant facts and circumstances.

    Indeed it seems it is time for all South Africans to have a serious and honest internal and inter racial, inter party politico debate.

    If Janusz Walos and Clive Derby-Lewis remain imprisoned, after serving nearly 20 years and are both elderly, it remains doubtful that the ANC can be seen as a dealing transparently and honestly if Nelson Mandela, in the TRC and his biography: "Long Walk to Freedom", has admitted to Church Street Massacre (in which 19 innocent people were murdered)- questions thus arise: is Chris Hani's death equal score for Eugene Terreblenche's, and is keeping Janusz Walos and Clive Derby-Lewis imprisoned is in the best interest of reconciliation in Southern Africa, and how does that amount to reconciliation at all?

    Is racial slander expressed and implied, political rhetoric about Nationalization and farm occupations by Malema any good or necessary in RSA, other than to create chaos and incitement, is the cart being put before the horse, is Robert Mugabe's land reform program successful if Zimbabwe is a net food importer and mines are dysfunctional?

    One needs to ask exacting questions: Would Mandela have approved, had he still been in power?

    How would he have managed the trumoil?

    And what is Zuma's actual position in this regard?

    Is Malema's objective rather more accurately one of non -cooperation and destruction?

    How it that, recently in vicinity of De Doorns in the Western Cape a black indigent Zimbabwean,was murdered by "liberation techniques" of burning to death, apparently over a issue to do with county boundaries, which were agreed by British and Boers nearly two centuries ago, perhaps it reflects the mindset of certain individuals who are indeed the "cattle" who vote for certain liberation organizations & movements with no plan except destruction as a venting mechanism for their frustrations.

    Does this seething hatred have a solution?


    The objectives of our country should not be mudslinging but rather education, job creation, industrialization, academic research and development of a constitutional democracy in order to create a South Africa where all persons born therein can live in peace if not also in harmony.

    And hopefully, where reconciliation after centuries of apparently exploited lifestyles which may require evolution and refinement can be completed if not in very least conducted in a fashion.

    The TRPSA calls for all South Africans to remain calm and mindful.

    Infact White Nationalism is perfectly normal as Black Nationalism is and indeed British National Party is one example of European White Nationalism, especially moderate versions thereof who wish to co –exist with neighbors , fundamentally we see absolutely nothing inappropriate with Afrikaners seeking self determination in a country of their own nor White Nationalism.

    The Truth and Reconciliation Party of South Africa also wishes the newly elected leader of the AWB well in his new job and intends for him fellowship and for a mellowed approach.
  • Lara Zhivago  - TRC was a PR publicity stunt..
    I guess the two faced hypocrits of the TRC party, have not confronted the reality that it was exactly their two-faced hypocrisy of pretense about this alleged 'TRC' democracy.. that waas the foundation of lies...

    If only the two-faced hypocrits would have confronted that true forgiveness can only occur sincerely and not by intellectual pretences, and had supported the hard road of true anger, hurts and fears told, we would nto be sitting with a fake TRC...

    As told by Dr. Truth, the most honest man on the planet... in his legal affidavit filed in the High Court Western Cape, Case # 19963-09: Affidavit of Brad Blanton, Ph.D.... THE TRC WAS A POLITICAL PR PUBLICITY STUNT... A HOAX!
  • Lara Zhivago  - Pity your facts aren't accurate
    SECRET Military Intelligence reports warning of Chris Hani's impending assassination have raised the startling possibility of a wider plot to kill the popular South African Communist Party leader before the 1994 elections.

    The Mail & Guardian is in possession of two documents, at least one which appears certain to have been delivered to the old South African Defence Force's Department of Military Intelligence (MI) before the assassination. Julie Wilken, long-time girlfriend of MI agent Eugene Riley, says in a sworn statement that she typed the documents, which Riley had composed for his MI handlers. She has passed a lie-detector test on the contents of her affidavit. Riley died of a single gunshot wound to his head on January 31 1994. His death remains a mystery.

    The documents raise the question why MI, pre-warned, had done nothing to prevent Hani's death. More surprisingly, they claim an unidentified group of African National Congress operatives had a hand in Hani's death.

    Excerpt the Guardian, PDF at: *****//***.scribd****/doc/29415893/
Write comment
Your Contact Details:
Comment:
Security
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.

Related news items:
Newer news items:
Older news items:

Move
-

Recent Articles

Top Headline

Energy security

Energy security

...

Read More...

Zimbabwe

Zimbabwe

Mugabe's zero-sum game President Robert Mugabe seems little constrained by the 2008 Global Political Agreement which established the coalition with the Movement for Democratic Change. Governance in Zimbabwe shows that the rule that “you are either with me or against me” continues to be a powerful force in deciding relations between...

Read More...

Springbok watch

Springbok watch

Coach needs glasses and a road map Call them legends of the fall, if you want. A year after their annus mirabilis, the Springbok team plummeted to number three in the world, conceded a record 22 tries in six matches and lost five out of six Vodacom Tri-Nations matches with only the World Cup in their trophy cabinet...

Read More...

Cricket scandal

Cricket scandal

Too little too late? If Hollywood were considering a remake of Sex, Lies and Videotape, there is some disturbing new material that would offer a perfect opportunity to write a sequel, but then they would have to be prepared to do some filming in the Asian subcontinent and interview a few bookmakers on cricket tests.

Read More...

Beyond the strike

Beyond the strike

Strike but one battle in ongoing war Truth is the first casualty of war. This old adage certainly rings true for South Africa at present as the country finds itself in the grip of a war of perceptions, speculation, claims and contradictions, as well as a vicious contest for power and spoils. A confusing and increasingly complex...

Read More...
Leadership magazine is South Africa's number one award winning business magazine having won the Tabbie Gold Award for Best Single Issue in the world (TABPI), PICA Awards for Magazine of the Year, Best Publication, Editor of the Year, Cover Design

The Leadership Bullentin


Archive