Saturday, September 04, 2010

Political re-alignment

smaller text tool iconmedium text tool iconlarger text tool icon
Malema_mainMalema – a poem called "History"

“History does not repeat itself, but it does rhyme,” the writer Mark Twain once commented. He could just as well have been referring to the Julius Malema-induced dramas within the ANC-led ruling alliance and the socalled verlig/verkrap battle within the ranks of its predecessor National Party (NP) government. Malema is increasingly starting to look like the ANC alliance’s incarnation of the late Dr Andries Treurnicht.

For our younger readers, Dr Andries Treurnicht was the frontman during the late 1970s and early 1980s for a group within the NP, dead set against any reform to the apartheid system. He became the leader of the Conservative Party.

As the marriage of convenience conceived by the freedom struggle between the ANC, SA Communist Party, the Congress of South African Trade Unions (Cosatu) and the South African National Civics Organisation (Sanco) increasingly comes under the strain of day-to-day government, political realignment is becoming increasingly inevitable.
When erstwhile top NP constitutional negotiator Roelf Meyer in 1997 broke away from the NP to form the United Democratic Movement in partnership with erstwhile “homeland” military leader Bantu Holomisa, it was in the belief that the realignment was at hand and the ANC about to split.

When Thabo Mbeki, in the run-up to the 1999 election, roped in Marthinus van Schalkwyk and what was left of the NP, it was part of a wider political deal. Dr Gatsha Buthelezi was party to that deal and would, in fact, have become deputy president of the country.

Like he so often did throughout his political career, Buthelezi at the last minute stepped back from the deal. Mbeki, however, went ahead with an attempt to implement a realignment strategy.

The rationale behind these moves was an attempt by Mbeki to consolidate the middle ground and rid himself of the stranglehold of the communist-led Left. In fact, after the election, there were some 'redeployments' throughout government structures in an attempt to sideline the Left.

Historic processes such as these are usually quite messy and seldom without a degree of disruption and always have actors who at times play apparently crucial roles way beyond their long-term importance.

The latest outburst by ANC Youth League (ANCYL) President Malema has, if anything, served more dramatically than ever before to lay bare the self-destructive tensions currently at play within the ruling alliance. However, it is more than likely merely another scene in a political drama of which the final act may still be some way off.

But, in what may be a rather desperate attempt by an almost powerless jacob Zuma within party political context to hold together the feuding alliance, the ANC president was seen trying to steer a neutral middle course, patch up relationships and sooth dented egos wherever he could – a task that may yet prove to be impossible.

As it did when the late John Vorster appointed Treurnicht to the position of deputy minister, but when – in a crucial caucus meeting – he was asked to rule out “power sharing” as becoming an option, he said he was “not willing to try to rule from the grave”.

The ANC and Zuma, however, do find themselves at something of a crossroads in their relationship with their left-wing allies, and the ruling alliance has drifted steadily into probably its greatest, and most self-destructive, crisis ever since the SACP and the ANCYL, among others, first played a critical role in ousting Mbeki at the ANC’s 2007 national conference in Polokwane and bringing Zuma to power.
Comments (4)
  • Corinne Winson  - We who sit at the sidelines
    One is never quite sure whether to laugh or cry, watching powerlessly from the sidelines of "the game" playing out amongst the political powers-that-be (or powers-that-want-to-be), holding one's breath, waiting for the inevitable fall-out that will affect us all.
  • Owen
    Hi Carol,you do not have to "sit at the sidelines,watching powerlessly"That is the main problem in South Africa right now,especially white South Africans.Ask any Zimbabwean white,they will tell you that that was their main mistake.Sitting on the sidelines playing dead when a dictator was busy entranching his hold on their country.When the woke up,it was already too late.In South Africa we have several options.Join the ANC enmass and vote for leadership change or better still force the DA to merge with a black party eg COPE vote in a black leader and take on the ANC.DA will never ever challenge the ANC on its own.It needs to change its approach in order to attract the majority of voters.This country is a democracy and we have the power to make a change if we unite across the colour divide.
  • Geoff Bird  - Titanic tussle in Eastern Cape
    Numerous Eastern Cape municipalities, including Nelson Mandela Bay Metro and Buffalo City, are being crippled in this battle which I am not convinced is between verlig and verkramp, but rather over who can get his hands on the cookie jar. I believe ideology has got nothing whatsoever to do with it. It's all about money, power and privilege, with service delivery and the plight of the sick and homeless the farthest things from the minds of the warring factions within the ANC Alliance. Sound a familiar African scenario? Factionalism is rife and will destroy us if we allow the Malemas of this world free reign.
  • Gordon  - The closest thing to planet of the Apes
    To deliberate about Malema and his useless contribution to Politics in this country would be futile. In the same vein as Peter Mokaba, perhaps in his drunken carelessness he will pick up a virus.We can hope...

    How he can even be accommodated in the current set up is embarrassing to us all as a nation. More scary is that we pay his salary as well.

    Perhaps 'joe public' is the monkey in this story.
Write comment
Your Contact Details:
Comment:
Security
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.

Related news items:
Newer news items:
Older news items:

Move
-

Recent Articles

Top Headline

Zimbabwe

Zimbabwe

Mugabe's zero-sum game President Robert Mugabe seems little constrained by the 2008 Global Political Agreement which established the coalition with the Movement for Democratic Change. Governance in Zimbabwe shows that the rule that “you are either with me or against me” continues to be a powerful force in deciding relations between...

Read More...

Final word

Final word

Its not always what you think During the public service strike there was one very clever poster displayed on our TV-screens. In fact it was so clever that it was really a pity that the teacher who had her face framed by a hole in the middle of the poster was not in her class teaching. The poster did, however aptly describe how many...

Read More...

Land grab

Land grab

Africa taken for a ride – again As Mozambique’s capital of Maputo and the city of Matola are experiencing violent riots because of rocketing prices of food and other key consumer goods, a report released in late August by Friends of the Earth...

Read More...

Charting a course through life

Charting a course through life

Success? It’s all in the numbers She is the epitome of the essential new breed of South African woman, and a woman who courageously takes things in her stride. Like coming from a rural Swaziland upbringing to earn several degrees and diplomas; being appointed to more professional and business boards than most people...

Read More...

Food security

Food security

Will Africa feed itself? Africa has a quarter of the world's arable land but produces only a tenth of our food. On the eve of a pan-African conference on food security, Lindiwe Sibanda asks how African farmers can turn things round, and what questions and answers you have when facing the huge challenges of maintaining and increasing...

Read More...
Leadership magazine is South Africa's number one award winning business magazine having won the Tabbie Gold Award for Best Single Issue in the world (TABPI), PICA Awards for Magazine of the Year, Best Publication, Editor of the Year, Cover Design

The Leadership Bullentin


Archive