Friday, September 03, 2010

Reader's Opinion

smaller text tool iconmedium text tool iconlarger text tool icon

Opinion_main“What can I get away with?” as a state of mind in South African leadership

By observing seemingly unconnected incidents in South Africa currently, the impression is becoming stronger that everything you can get away with is acceptable. “What can I get away with” seems to have become a state of mind in South African leadership.

(We invite our readers to submit opinion pieces of not more than 800 words for consideration. Such contributions, as the one published here, does not necessarily reflect  the opinion of the publishers or editorial staff of Leadership Intelligence Bulletin.)


Recently, President Jacob Zuma nominated (appointed?) Judge Sandile Ngcobo to succeed Chief Justice Pius Langa when the latter’s term of office expires later this year.  When challenged in Parliament about the fact that Judge Ngcobo has only two years left of his term as a judge of the Constitutional Court, the president’s reaction was that there is nothing in the Constitution that prevents him from appointing someone with only two years left in the Constitutional Court.
And, that is undoubtedly correct.


Recently Ken Owen questioned, in an article in "Business Day", Judge Johann Kriegler’s decision to take the Judicial Service Commission (JSC) to court on its handling of the Judge Hlophe issue. His opinion was that Judge Kriegler was starting a fight he was bound to lose on the PR front in the eyes of the majority of South Africans.  
He may have a very good point.


He also referred to Judge Kriegler’s criticism of the process for appointing judges followed by the JSC and his reference to the way in which the JSC humiliates white judges and commented that they should “grow up”. He opines that it is to be expected that the JSC would humiliate white candidates because “it’s payback time”.
That may be a valid point as well.

What is the link between these incidents?

In both cases, it can be argued that it has everything to do with a mindset that whatever you can get away with, goes.
The president can undoubtedly appoint a new Chief Justice who will have to be replaced again in two years. Whether it is the right thing to do, the wise thing to do, the best thing to do – bearing in mind the president’s duty to do what is in the best interests of all South Africans – is a different question.  
Why did he pick Judge Ngcobo? He says because Judge Ngcobo is well qualified and experienced – probably true as well. But that can be said of a number of others. In fact, ALL the judges of the Constitutional Court should pass that test and probably do.
Was this a decision that was expedient, to mark time until the Hlophe smoke cloud has blown away?
Why did the majority of the JSC decide not to pursue the matter against Judge Hlophe? Was that the right thing, the wise thing to do? How can it be? How can it be wise to allow a cloud to hang over the Judge-President of one of the major seats of the High Court and over two judges of the Constitutional Court?  

Because it would increase tension between races if they didn’t? How can that be? The two Constitutional Court judges involved are as black as Judge Hlophe. So, too, are Judges Mpati (President of the Supreme Court of Appeal) and Ngoepe (Judge-President of the North Gauteng High Court), who formed part of the minority opinion that the matter should be pursued.

Or was it an expedient decision which was more centred around preventing the embarrassment that could flow from a full inquiry? Embarrassment for whom?
How can it be the wise thing, the right thing to do, to humiliate candidates for appointment as judges who appear before the JSC?
Should South Africans not be entitled to expect their president to be looking to do the right thing, the wise thing, when appointing a Chief Justice? Should they not be entitled to expect the JSC to act with wisdom and propriety when dealing with the crucial duty of appointing judges, and refrain from petty revenge?  Should they not be entitled to expect this body to act in a transparent way to enable clouds over the head of judges to be removed and enhance the image of the judiciary as a body above party politics?
Is it too much to ask to hope for leadership in South Africa which strives for wisdom and propriety instead of expediency? Or have we lost Madiba’s spirit of wisdom, propriety and reconciliation for ever?

Comments (0)
Write comment
Your Contact Details:
Comment:
Security
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.

Related news items:
Newer news items:
Older news items:

Move
-

Recent Articles

Top Headline

Zimbabwe

Zimbabwe

Mugabe's zero-sum game President Robert Mugabe seems little constrained by the 2008 Global Political Agreement which established the coalition with the Movement for Democratic Change. Governance in Zimbabwe shows that the rule that “you are either with me or against me” continues to be a powerful force in deciding relations between...

Read More...

Final word

Final word

Its not always what you think During the public service strike there was one very clever poster displayed on our TV-screens. In fact it was so clever that it was really a pity that the teacher who had her face framed by a hole in the middle of the poster was not in her class teaching. The poster did, however aptly describe how many...

Read More...

Land grab

Land grab

Africa taken for a ride – again As Mozambique’s capital of Maputo and the city of Matola are experiencing violent riots because of rocketing prices of food and other key consumer goods, a report released in late August by Friends of the Earth...

Read More...

Charting a course through life

Charting a course through life

Success? It’s all in the numbers She is the epitome of the essential new breed of South African woman, and a woman who courageously takes things in her stride. Like coming from a rural Swaziland upbringing to earn several degrees and diplomas; being appointed to more professional and business boards than most people...

Read More...

Food security

Food security

Will Africa feed itself? Africa has a quarter of the world's arable land but produces only a tenth of our food. On the eve of a pan-African conference on food security, Lindiwe Sibanda asks how African farmers can turn things round, and what questions and answers you have when facing the huge challenges of maintaining and increasing...

Read More...
Leadership magazine is South Africa's number one award winning business magazine having won the Tabbie Gold Award for Best Single Issue in the world (TABPI), PICA Awards for Magazine of the Year, Best Publication, Editor of the Year, Cover Design

The Leadership Bullentin


Archive