Are plastic alternatives a blessing or a curse?

Never before has the issue of plastic pollution and, specifically, plastics in our oceans received so much attention on a global scale. Consumers are encouraged to “choose to refuse” single-use plastics


Calls for action such as these make it clear that consumers around the world are tired of visible litter. By responding on social media platforms with a zealous passion, they demand to see an end to plastic packagings such as carrier bags, drinking straws and cotton ear buds. Anton Hanekom, the Executive Director at Plastics|SA discusses the matter.

Recognising an opportunity to gain significant marketing and PR mileage, some retailers and brand owners were quick to respond to these public outcries by introducing alternatives. Alternatives included paper bags and piloting a compostable bag made from starches, cellulose, vegetable oils and combinations as an “environmentally-friendly alternative to plastic bags” to replace all plastic carrier bags, barrier bags and fruit and vegetable bags. Is this the solution?

To the uninformed, this might seem to be an excellent and practical solution to solve an irritating problem. The reality, unfortunately, is far from the truth. Many of the so-called “plastic alternatives” that are now flooding the market have not been properly evaluated.

Offering a compostable carrier bag to consumers sounds good in theory; however, further scrutiny reveals that these bags and other biodegradable plastic products will only degrade in a properly managed composting facility and definitely not in the normal suburban compost heap. If not kept under ideal conditions, these bags will not biodegrade and are most likely to end up in one of the country’s landfills (also not an ideal composting environment) or worse, in the recycling stream where it will contaminate the entire stream and render more material unrecyclable.

Is recycling the answer?

South Africa has a robust and well-developed plastics recycling industry that provided jobs to more than 52 000 collectors who collect waste that is mechanically recycled into new raw materials (more than 313 700 tonnes of plastic material) in 2017 alone. Thanks to their dedicated efforts and the South Africans committed to recycling, 214 220 tonnes of CO² and enough landfill space to fill 714 Olympic-sized swimming pools were saved in one year—this is the equivalent weight of 560 Airbus A380 aeroplanes, saving enough fuel to keep 178 000 cars on the road for one year.

Unfortunately, the same cannot be said of these replacement materials. All of these products will eventually reach the end of life and will need to be discarded. A non-woven plastic re-usable plastic bag, for example, is not currently recycled in South Africa owing to the fact that the stitching and webbing used in the manufacture of the bag are made of different materials to the bulk of the bag.

Likewise, drinking straws made from alternate materials such as glass or bamboo tubing are neither currently recycled in South Africa nor collected by waste pickers due to their low value and weight.

On the other hand, when combined with a responsible, well-managed waste management system, a recyclable product not only underwrites and supports a circular economy, but also ensures that precious resources are protected and reused for as long as possible. Rejecting a “fit for purpose” plastic packaging material with a low carbon footprint in favour of an alternative material that is imported, more expensive, with a higher carbon footprint and potentially uses scarce food resources as a raw material could be creating an even bigger problem, rather than solving this one.

Plastics don’t litter—people do. Opting for biodegradable packaging is not going to change the human behaviour of littering. Consumers need to commit to protecting our environment and educating themselves on the facts around packaging alternatives, and the benefits of effective plastic recycling and the correct disposal of materials they no longer need. The marketing jargon promoting these replacement materials should be researched before boldly switching to alternative materials.

Similarly, it is of vital importance that legislators, the local government, consumers and the plastics industry continue to work together on developing solutions that are sustainable, well researched and properly evaluated.

Only through this combined effort can we ensure that the resources are utilised and managed efficiently and cater to an increasing population seeking the unrivalled benefits offered by plastics packaging when it comes to preventing food waste, extending the shelf life of products and protection against breakage. 

comments powered by Disqus

This edition

Issue 414


Leadership_Mag JJ's View - The rise and fall of leadership in the 26 years of democracy. #JJsview #leadership #may2020 Read on pag… 8 days - reply - retweet - favorite

Leadership_Mag Leadership May 2020 Cover Story - The future of South Africa post the Global Pandemic. Read it in our new interacti… 8 days - reply - retweet - favorite

Leadership_Mag The interactive version of the May 2020 #Leadership magazine is available now. 13 days - reply - retweet - favorite